Customer Feedback Best Practices

Case Study: Beating the Market with Customer Satisfaction

Wall Street pressure pushes companies to cut customer service costs to hit the next quarter — even though the University of Michigan's hedge portfolio based on the American Customer Satisfaction Index shows customer satisfaction beats the market. Here's the case study, the research, and what it implies for treating customer service as an investment instead of a cost line.

By Adam Ramshaw 2 min read
Case Study Chart — illustration for Case Study: Beating the Market with Customer Satisfaction

If you’re looking to boost customer satisfaction, one of the most promising places to start is customer service. Unfortunately, it’s also a place where long-term goals tend to buckle under short-term financial pressures. Companies try to meet Wall Street’s immediate demands by cutting costs through automation and outsourcing—despite a growing body of research conclusively showing that customers are fed up with lousy service and that increased satisfaction has a positive impact on consumer spending, cash flow, and business performance.

In a groundbreaking 2006 study, University of Michigan business professor Claes Fornell and colleagues showed the relationship between customer satisfaction and financial success by creating a hedge portfolio in which stocks are bought long and sold short in response to changes in the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI). Developed by the University of Michigan’s National Quality Research Center, the ACSI is an indicator of economic success that reflects levels of customer satisfaction with goods and services purchased from about 200 companies in more than 40 industries; it’s based on interviews with more than 65,000 U.S. consumers each year.

Collectively, as the exhibit “Why Service Matters” demonstrates, the companies with high customer-satisfaction scores have blown the S&P 500 out of the water, especially over the last few years. Not only have they produced higher stock returns, but their stock values and cash flows have been less volatile.

Case Study Chart

How are these results possible, given efficient-market theory, which says you can’t consistently outperform the market? It’s because today’s stock valuation methods fail to incorporate the kind of information that forms the basis for making stock trades in the ACSI portfolio. If they did, the ACSI portfolio would closely track the S&P 500.

Download

Download the full case study here: Beating the Market with Customer Satisfaction.

Back to Blog

Related Posts

View All Posts »
5 Best Practices for Effective Customer Feedback Programs

5 Best Practices for Effective Customer Feedback Programs

US industry has spent USD 800 million a year on customer satisfaction for a decade, and the American Customer Satisfaction Index has barely moved. That's because satisfaction isn't the goal — loyalty is, and loyalty needs a different program. Here are the five steps to building a customer feedback program that actually moves the business, starting with linking loyalty to a financial outcome.

Customer Feedback Surveys: The 6 TRACER Attributes Your Survey Must Have

Customer Feedback Surveys: The 6 TRACER Attributes Your Survey Must Have

You've brainstormed, wordsmithed and polished the survey questions — but if you skip the TRACER check before you hit send, the survey will quietly under-deliver. TRACER (random sample, respect, actionable, clear, easy, relevant) is the six-attribute filter your survey must pass. Here's each attribute explained, with the most common ways surveys fail each one.

Research: 6 Key Drivers of Successful Customer Feedback Programs

Research: 6 Key Drivers of Successful Customer Feedback Programs

After 15 years of running customer feedback programs, we wanted to move past anecdote and see which attributes statistically predict success. So we surveyed 80 practitioners and ran the analysis. Here are the six drivers and seven key takeaways that came out — including the engagement and reporting moves that consistently separate the programs that stick from the ones that quietly stall.

Customer Advocacy: How High-Performing Companies Set Themselves Apart

Customer Advocacy: How High-Performing Companies Set Themselves Apart

Some companies operate at high performance year after year, and others scrap to stay in business. The variable most often missing from the under-performers is genuine customer advocacy — a way of operating that goes well beyond fee-for-service. Here's how high-performing companies set themselves apart, written by guest contributor Seb Atkinson.